Re: Robert Plant & Jimmmy Page in Court
Copyright law, in music, is exceedingly difficult to prove. I enquired years ago over a song I had written, the main melody line had been 'nicked'.
I had even taken the precaution of posting the manuscript to myself as soon as I had written it, so that I had a Royal Mail official date stamp directly on to the reverse of my manuscript ! Even so the lawyer I spoke to said that there was not enough of the melody on the 'new' song to guarantee winning the case, and it would be so costly to bring to court ! I didn't take it any further. The group I was in at the time "Unit Three Plus One" made a 'demo' disc at the back end of 1969 with four tracks on it (an EP) and one of those tracks was "Silently", it became obvious to us that record companies 'nicked' original songs from such 'soft pressings - demo discs' knowing full well that it was highly unlikely that any of the original writers would sue them, because of the high court costs.
This is the song that had 'nicked' my melody line.
My song was called 'Silently' and the 'new' song was entitled 'Today I killed a man I didn't know' and was recorded by several well known artistes ! A friend of mine rang me up to tell me they had just heard it on the radio, on a program that played the 'B' side of various 'Hits'. My melody was on the 'B' side of "My Baby Loves Lovin'" by White Plains in early 1970, I think (It may have been "Julie Do Ya Love Me?" out at the back end of 1970).
My song was a love song, but the 'new' song was an anti war song about the American Civil War !
On YouTube, various people recorded this song -
Words & Music credits go to Roger Cook and Roger Greenaway. (no mention of Gill Dixon !!!! grrrrrrrrrr)
The Fortunes, Nash Chase, White Plains, P. J. Proby, Roger Cook (ex David & Jonathon), Edward Woodward, The Family Dogg, Masanobu Tadeta.