Re: Should Madeleine McCann's parents accept blame?

Sniffer dogs are not always reliable they will react to other things ie pork .
Given the corrupt nature of a amaral he could have quite easily planted markers to fit his far fetched theory.

The personal attack tactic doesn't work on this forum unless it really is a personal attack on another member so try another way to flame the topic.
It's obvious to me you are a troll .
Have a nice day

Re: Should Madeleine McCann's parents accept blame?

Blimey we have some esteemed company here a experienced dog handler who knows a dog didn't alert to what he was trained for.Pork thats a new one,back it with evidence,the judge was perfectly happy to state as a fact.

Human blood and cadervine,where do you get the pork from,talk about conspiracy.

Re: Should Madeleine McCann's parents accept blame?

When the argument is lost the abuse begins.
There is I suppose a report button available,use it wisely,calling some one a troll is personal is it not.

Re: Should Madeleine McCann's parents accept blame?

Caricature, if you believe the McCanns killed their child, you are entitled to your opinion, but the majority do not believe that. If there was any real evidence to prove Amarals story they would have been arrested, so there is obviously none.
Neither you or anyone else knows, for sure, what happened to Madeleine so, with that in mind, surely the sensible thing to do is state your opinion and let others state theirs. There is no prize for whoever is right, because we will probably never know for sure!

Re: Should Madeleine McCann's parents accept blame?

I'd like you to point out where its said I think the parents killed Madeleine ,I'm asking those that state an abduction took place to back it up it up with hard facts,not just because she's not there.There does seem to be evidence of an abduction not happening,SY can't find one.

Re: Should Madeleine McCann's parents accept blame?

What else could have happened ?

Re: Should Madeleine McCann's parents accept blame?

Sorry I thought you were indicating that with the mention of blood being found in the McCanns hire car( one assumes there would be no blood if she wasn't hurt). The word abduction was used because that is what most of us believe happened, but we cannot prove it anymore than you can prove otherwise. I am not sure what you believe happened to her, because you haven't said, but as none of us actually know we are just saying what we feel in our hearts.

Re: Should Madeleine McCann's parents accept blame?

Reading some of that nonsense posted by people trying to refute the distinct probability that Madeleine was abduction by a pedophile who had been watching the children or that the event was part of a burglary gone wrong, might I suggest little green men in a space ship abducted her a proposition which is really no more ridiculous than the silly arguments put forward by those who take pleasure in twisting the knife into the McCanns.

I personally find the whole debate pointless, the only people who know the truth are Madeleine herself and the person responsible for her disappearance and they are unlikely to tell us.

Anything else is pure speculation and gossip ..

Re: Should Madeleine McCann's parents accept blame?

Oh come on Muddy , you must see that undermining the aspects of the investigation you don't like or believe to be true or untrue rather throws everything into question concerning the events that allegedly happened that night.

Hey .. I've known caricature years and can vouch for him. He's not a troll.

Re: Should Madeleine McCann's parents accept blame?

Well said Meg!