Re: What A Loss (?)
Originally Posted by
bakerman
->
No insult intended but, for the life of me I can not understand why the people of the U.K. need a monarchy in the first place. And then to be forced to pay for their every little need and desire. It seems to me that the days of having a monarchy are long passed. Seriously, what makes them royal in the 1st place ? Hmm ? Just merely being born ?
Well it stems from time immemorial. In any community there was a leader, usually a male and the strongest one there.
Later, as communities expanded to nations, the leader was known as the King and, again, was the strongest man there. He was supported by other men who were given responsibility for ruling (and collecting taxes) in their own county (Counts, later called Earls in this country although to be accurate the term Earl preceded the term Count - Comte in the case of the Normans).
At the time of Oliver Cromwell, he and his supporters decided that they'd had enough of the King because he was living the life of Riley and they weren't, so along came the 'Commonwealth'.
A few years later, they decided that having a King wasn't such a bad idea after all, but when reinstating him (a different one, actually, the old one had been beheaded) they decided that he and his successors should not be all powerful any more, so restrictions were put in place and Parliament held the real power.
And here's the crunch. Suddenly, the King was no longer as influential and Parliament, in return for taking all his income from taxes and keeping them for themselves, agreed to pay him the 'Civil List'. That is what we have today. Instead of the King (or Queen) receiving all the taxes and using the money as he wished, Parliament grabs the lot and uses the money as
they wish - largely for their own benefit, of course! In return, the Queen receives a small portion of that money for her benefit.
In my opinion, the Queen is beneficial to this country and draws in more money from abroad than she receives.
Republicans should be careful in insisting that the monarchy should be disestablished because their taxes will not reduce; the money that is presently paid to the Queen will instead be added to what the government receives and will still be irresponsibly spent - foreign aid, for example.
I can assure you that if there was no Royal Family we would not be better off ourselves. If anything things would be worse for us!