Re: Where are the doom-mongers now?
Originally Posted by
Dachs
->
German companies have always invested in the UK. No doubt, the UK is one of the most important markets for German companies who have invested 160 billion Euros in the UK and employ about 400,000 people in 2,500 German branches. They have always taken a strong interest in British-German trade relations and were kind of caught on the hop when Brexit came although it was to some extent predictable.
The British-German Chamber of Commerce (BGCoC) does not seem to be as neutral as The German Chamber of Industry and Commerce who in its recent survey "Going international 2021" including 1,500 German companies states that business has been on the decline since Brexit. 57% of German companies are expecting a further deterioration of business relationships in the 12 months ahead while 15 per cent are planning on relocating business activities to other markets or have already done so. A glance at BGCoC's website shows that there are no recent documents supporting the statements made by DE. What can be read there, though, is "One should not expect the EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement to undergo major changes in the years to come – it is what it is and, in essence, it is now about adjusting one’s business to the new framework. "
So, that seems to be somewhat in contrast to what DE is reporting, sadly without substantiating its claims.
Needless to say that trade relations will pick up a again sooner or later but what evidence is there that this is happening right now?
https://www.dihk.de/de/themen-und-po...rtschaft-35870
https://grossbritannien.ahk.de/brexi...haeftsfuehrers
Statistics take months to gather and collate so what is happening now won't be known for another three months or more.
Even then there have always been anomolies, so years would be better - decades possibly before we know how trade is
really doing.
Your input is interesting but (with my apologies here for being brutally honest) it doesn't really mean very much for a number of reasons, one of which you have already hinted-at which is that different chambers of commerce have different stances.
Another which you have again touched-upon is that German business has indeed seen decreasing exports to the UK since the referendum in 2016 while by contrast UK exports to Germany - while declining - have been doing so at a slower rate.
So we are back to forecasts, and you've supplied those from German sources regarding what they think will happen to German/UK trade.
If these are even reasonably accurate then other forecasts suggest that they aren't going to have any great impact upon the UK economy because regarding this year and the next few years these suggest that UK growth will be well ahead of Germany's.
The IMF forecast for 2021 says UK = 5.3% vs Germany 3.6% and the figures are similar for 2022.
As you might have seen in other parts of the forum, those IMF estimates are on the low side for the UK from recent forecasts with the consensus suggesting UK growth will be ahead of every other major economy for the next few years.
But these, like your own examples, are forecasts.
Educated guesses if you will.
The reality at the end of the day could well be very different.
But there are a few pointers that in fact the UK is indeed (for now at least) doing as well as the growth forecasts suggest.
* A record £5.1 billion has been funnelled by investors into British startups in the first three months of this year, accounting for seven of the top 10 biggest funding rounds in the period.
* Unemployment is steady at 4.9 (lower than Germany) ; inflation has risen slightly to 1%; and optimism among UK business leaders has hit record highs
* The government's popularity has risen to a 14-point lead over the main opposition, suggesting that the public are if not rapturous at least acknowledging that their personal circumstances are good enough to keep them happy.
* As earlier: one in 4 houses new-to-market are selling within a week - and prices continue to rise too. You can't sell houses if nobody can afford them or if they don't want to buy, so people are obviously considering their futures to be secure-enough to buy what is for many the largest single purchase they will ever make.
There's more but I risk being accused of waxing lyrical, and I'm not.
But IMHO for the first time in a long, long time this country - despite years of dire warnings, remember - has the opportunity to do well and people are beginning to increasingly see that for themselves.
Even in these forums there are contributors saying that they are busier than they have ever been.
Again IMHO but now that the world is on the cusp of a new era it is an ideal time to change direction from the older ways of doing things that have never worked very well, and that doesn't only apply to our trading relationships.
Whether or not we do indeed make the most of such an opprtunity is of course another thing entirely and here we are again having gone full-circle because we again won't really know how that has gone for decades.